Convertible car seats are a fantastic thing! They allow a car seat to grow from being a rear-facing to a front-facing, and even sometimes into a booster seat!
Two great convertible car seat options are the Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite and the Graco Nautilus.
Based on these four categories: weight restrictions, safety features, average consumer rating and parent-friendly additions, we are able to provide you with a great start to your car seat shopping!
Weight Restrictions
The Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite is a three-mode convertible car seat. With three modes, there comes three weight restrictions.
When used in the rear-facing mode, the weight restriction is between 5 lbs. and 35 lbs. When used in the front-facing mode, the weight restriction is between 22 lbs. and 40 lbs. When used as a booster seat, the weight restrictions are between 40 lbs. and 100 lbs.
The Graco Nautilus also has three modes, but is aimed at slightly older children, so they are all front-facing options.
The first mode (using the built-in harness) has weight restrictions of 22 lbs. to 65 lbs. Without using the built-in harness (just using the car seatbelt) has weight restrictions of 30 lbs. to 100 lbs. The last mode (without built-in harness and without the back support) has weight restrictions of 40 lbs. to 100 lbs.
Safety Features
The Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite has some well-recommended safety features on it. It boasts a quickfit harness system, energy absorbing foam, and adjustable headrest to grow with the child.
The Graco Nautilus boasts a steel reinforced frame for extra durability. This model is also extensively crash tested to meet all safety standards.
Average Consumer Rating
The Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite is rated, on average by consumers, at a 4 out of 5 stars. There are a lot of first-hand reviews of this model where children walked away from devastating crashes without being harmed due to the safety features on this car seat.
The Graco Nautilus is rated slightly higher than the Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite, on average, with a 4.5 stars out of 5 stars. Most of the consumers say that it’s a great value for it’s price.
Parent-friendly Additions
The Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite has a number of parent-friendly additions to make any parent smile. They include:
- Pivoting armrests
- Removable cup holder
- Multi-position reclining options
- Infant head support
- Removable car seat pad for cleaning
- 6 great colors to choose from:
- Beaumont (tan / black)
- Bromley (dark grey / black)
- Lamont (light grey / black / white piping)
- Pretty Paws (light brown / light pink / pink leopard print pattern)
- Quartz (black / light grey)
- Seaside Bay (light blue / dark grey / bright green piping)
The Graco Nautilus also has quite the lineup of parent-friendly additions. They are:
- Five-point harness
- Double cup holder
- Three-position recline options
- Car seat pad is machine washable
- 6 fantastic color options:
- Carson (dark grey / light grey / teal piping / checker pattern)
- Catia (grey / pink piping / flower pattern)
- Garnet (grey / red accents)
- Gavit (dark grey / light grey / green piping)
- Matrix (black / light grey / green piping)
- Valerie (light grey / pink / taupe)
Overall Product Recommendation
The overall product recommendation for these two car seat models would go to the Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite. The convertible aspect, ranging from rear-facing to booster seat is appealing for parents who do not want to purchase more than one car seat for their child. This seat can grow with the child from birth until toddler years.
CLICK HERE TO GET SAFETY 1st TODAY WITH FREE SHIPPING!
The Graco Nautilus, unfortunately, is not a rear-facing car seat and thus cannot be used for infants.
Other CAR SEATS Comparisons
- Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Safety 1st Guide Air
- Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Eddie Bauer XRS 65
- Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Graco My Ride 65
- Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Evenflo Sureride
- Graco Size4Me 65 vs Graco Nautilus 65
- Baby Trend Flex-Loc vs Graco Snugride
- Baby Trend Flex-Loc vs Chicco Keyfit
- Evenflo Nurture vs Evenflo Embrace
- Graco 4Ever vs Britax
- Safety 1st Grow And Go vs Graco Extend2Fit
- Graco Nautilus 65 vs Graco Nautilus 80
- Evenflo Tribute LX vs Evenflo Sureride DLX
- Graco Size4Me 65 vs Graco 4Ever
- Graco Size4Me 65 vs Graco Extend2Fit
- Safety 1st Grow N Go vs Graco 4Ever
Other Graco Nautilus Comparisons
- Graco Argos 80 Elite vs. Graco Nautilus: Which Graco is for you?
- Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite vs. Graco Nautilus: Convertible car seats for ultimate safety and efficiency!
- Graco Smart Seat Vs. Nautilus: Which is the Better Value?
- Graco Nautilus vs. Diono Radian RXT
- Graco Nautilus vs Britax Frontier
- Britax Marathon vs. Graco Nautilus
- Graco Nautilus vs. Britax Pioneer
Other Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite Comparisons
- Safety 1st Alpha Elite 65 vs Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite: One Small Difference can Make a Big Deal
- Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite vs. Complete Air: Safety 1st convertible car seat options
- Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite vs. Graco Nautilus: Convertible car seats for ultimate safety and efficiency!
- Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite vs. Alpha Elite 65: Two amazing models from Safety 1st!
- Safety 1st Alpha Omega Elite vs. Complete Air 65: Two great Safety 1st Convertible Car Seats!